Best Jewelry Insurance

July 8, 2021

Gold and silver jewelry and precious stones are valuable assets, which is why insurance for jewelry exists in the first place. But not all insurance companies are the same. Since jewelry is a significant investment, it pays to get the best jewelry insurance you can find. And that’s what we are going to talk about in this review.

Methodology

You already know about homeowners insurance, pets insurance, and even individual insurance. But what about getting a jewelry insurance policy? Well, if you have been wondering about the same thing, then you’re at the right place.

We selected the best jewelry insurance companies by researching multiple insurance policies, then picking the top contenders.

We chose the best providers based on:

  • The type of coverage offered
  • The policy terms
  • The customer satisfaction rating
  • The company’s reputation (AM Best, BBB) 

We’ve also broken down all of this information into digestible, bite-size pieces so that it’s easily understandable even by people who are new to the jewelry insurance market.

Individual Companies Reviews

If you are into purchasing jewelry from Etsy and other online marketplaces or haven’t moved past the costume jewelry phase, then you probably haven’t thought about getting insurance on jewelry, and you don’t need to. 

However, the situation is different if you tend to purchase your jewelry from large brands and fashion stores that feature precious stones and metals and come with a fancy price tag. In this case, you absolutely need to find a reliable jewelry insurance company.

Similar to other types of insurance, there are many options to choose from when it comes to getting your jewelry insurance. Along with basic personal jewelry insurance, there are also homeowners and renters insurance offering jewelry coverage. 

Here, we’re going to share a few jewelry insurance reviews of the best providers in town.

Product
Rating
Key Features
Website
1
OVERALL RATING
4.3
Expert Review
  • Best Overall
  • Policies tailored to your requirements
  • Affordable prices
PRICE: $
Get a Deal
2
OVERALL RATING
4.2
Expert Review
  • Most Comprehensive Coverage
  • Affordable rates
  • Get quotes easily
PRICE: $
Get a Deal
3
OVERALL RATING
4.3
Expert Review
  • Best Personalized Experience
  • Easy to get quotes
  • An advanced underwriting process
PRICE: $
Get a Deal
4
OVERALL RATING
4.3
Expert Review
  • Best for No Deductible Coverage
  • Loss due to natural disasters covered
  • No hidden service charges
PRICE: $
Get a Deal
5
OVERALL RATING
4.4
Expert Review
  • Best for New Jewelry
  • Superior customer service
  • Agreed value feature
PRICE: $
Get a Deal
6
OVERALL RATING
4.5
Expert Review
  • Best for New Jewelry
  • Easy to get quotes, great prices
  • Reliable coverage
PRICE: $
Get a Deal
7
OVERALL RATING
4.8
Expert Review
  • Best for Bundling Policies
  • Affordable and comprehensive coverage
  • Affordable prices
PRICE: $
Get a Deal
8
OVERALL RATING
4.7
Expert Review
  • Best for Less Expensive Jewelry
  • Bundling with other coverage options available
  • Reliable service
PRICE: $
Get a Deal
9
OVERALL RATING
4.6
Expert Review
  • Best for Antique Jewelry
  • Coverage for other valuables, such as collectibles, fine art, etc., included
  • No deductibles
PRICE: $
Get a Deal

Jewelers Mutual Insurance is a trusted name on the insurance market, specifically for jewelry. The high service quality it offers can be gauged by the many positive Jewelers Mutual reviews left online by satisfied customers. 

Jewelers Mutual Insurance Group has been providing services since 1913 and has garnered quite a following since then because of its premium insurance products. This is reflected by the company’s A+ rating by AM Best and a positive BBB rating.

What makes this jewelry insurance provider special is that it allows customers to get a quote for their jewelry online in a matter of minutes. Furthermore, the policies can be customized according to your specific requirements. However, the jewelry insurance policies exclude coverage due to a lawful seizure or general wear and tear.

The provider also makes it easy to make a claim and has an extremely straightforward follow-up process with exceptional customer service. 

Finally, the best part is that the premium is just a small percentage of the total value of the insured jewelry.

PROS:
  • Coverage for physical loss and damage
  • Easy claims process
  • Affordable prices
CONS:
  • No coverage for loss of jewelry due to lawful seizures and wear and tear

Lavalier jewelry insurance is a well-known company, providing worldwide coverage. 

According to the many Lavalier jewelry insurance reviews available online, the company offers exceptional quality service, although the coverage is limited to $50,000 per piece (higher limits may be considered). Therefore, Lavalier might be a poor choice for those who tend to purchase incredibly expensive jewelry. Also, appraisals are required for pieces worth $5,000 or more.

The provider uses Berkley Asset Protection as its partner for underwriting, which offers its services on behalf of the Berkley National Insurance Company and boasts a positive A+ rating from AM Best. 

Lavalier provides many advantages to its users, such as fast quotes, excellent customer service, and worldwide coverage.

PROS:
  • Reputable insurance provider
  • All-risk coverage
  • Easy to get quotes
  • Affordable prices
CONS:
  • Not the best option for very expensive jewelry
  • Appraisal required for jewelry worth more than $50,000

JIBNA Jewelry insurance has been in business since 1975, so it is considered to be one of the oldest providers of jewelry insurance in the country. Jewelry Insurance Brokerage of North America (JIBNA) also enjoys exceptional reviews because of its high-quality service, along with the AM Best A+ rating.

One of the company’s major selling points is its advanced underwriting process that takes away the guesswork when choosing the best coverage option. You only need to pay 1-2% of the jewelry’s value. Moreover, the company has excellent customer reviews and offers streamlined service for those who are looking for reliable and affordable jewelry insurance

PROS:
  • An advanced underwriting process
  • Positive ratings
  • 1-2% of the jewelry value charged for the policy
CONS:
  • Agent required for filing claims and getting quotes

If you were searching for jewelry insurance, you would probably come across many positive Zillion jewelry insurance reviews

We believe Zillion insurance should be right up your alley if you’d like to get an affordable insurance policy for your most prized jewelry.

The jewelry insurance provider uses underwriting by AXA XL, which comes with exceptional financial strength and a positive A+ rating by AM Best. 

In addition, Zillion stands out because it offers worldwide coverage for all types of loss, including natural disasters.

PROS:
  • Coverage for loss due to natural disasters
  • Cancellation possible anytime within 30 days for a full refund
  • No hidden service charges
  • No pricey deductibles
CONS:
  • Jewelry appraisal needed
  • Lots of personal information required to get a quote

5. Review

OVERALL RATING 4.4

Chubb Jewelry insurance has been around since 1792, which makes it one of the oldest insurance providers in the country. The company offers many benefits, including an agreed value feature, which basically means that you will receive 100% of the promised amount. 

Being such an old player in the insurance niche, Chubb also enjoys stellar ratings, including an A++ rating from AM Best.

While the insurance provider offers valuables insurance for your jewelry and other expensive items, customers can also purchase individualized coverage to get more out of their insurance policy. 

The best advantage of using Chubb insurance is that it only requires an appraisal for jewelry items worth more than $100,000. 

Moreover, Chubb is known for delivering superior customer service and after-sales support, which can easily be gauged by many positive customer reviews.

PROS:
  • Agreed value feature
  • Appraisals required for jewelry worth $100,000 or more
  • Excellent ratings
CONS:
  • Work with an independent agent

If you’ve been in the market for jewelry insurance, then you may have come across many GemShield insurance reviews. 

GemShield insurance was founded in 1997 and is considered one of the best options for new jewelry. 

The company’s policies are underwritten by Berkley Asset Protection. Moreover, they are offered via the Wasserman & Wexler Insurance Agency, LLC, so you know you’re getting a quality service right off the bat.

One of the main selling points of GemShield jewelry insurance is that it offers coverage for mysterious disappearance as well. Moreover, the insurance provider boasts positive ratings and offers many features and benefits that help it stand out from the rest. 

You can get a free quote on the website with insurance policies costing no more than 2% of the insured jewelry value per year. 

The insurance provider has stellar customer reviews due to its fast processing time and excellent customer support.

PROS:
  • Reliable coverage
  • Work with the jeweler of your choice
  • Worldwide coverage
CONS:
  • Maximum policy cap of $100,000 ($35,000 per piece), exceptions might be considered

When it comes to jewelry insurance, GEICO is perhaps not one of the first names that spring to mind. However, according to GEICO jewelry insurance reviews, the provider offers excellent insurance and comprehensive coverage for those who want to insure their jewelry.

GEICO was acquired by Berkshire Hathaway in 1996. Since then, the insurance provider’s ratings have soared, and it now enjoys a positive A++ rating by AM Best, based on its exceptional financial strength. Over the years, it has garnered much respect in the insurance niche.

The coverage provider offers single and bundled options, which makes it easier for users to get the exact coverage they need while still keeping premiums low. In addition, the company allows customers to get a free quote online, with policies typically costing no more than 2% of the total value of the insured jewelry.

PROS:
  • Coverage for all major perils
  • Affordable prices
  • Worldwide coverage
  • No need for an appraisal for purchasing coverage
CONS:
  • Jewelry appraisal required before filing a claim

So, you want insurance for your jewelry, but you do not want to take out a stand-alone policy. Well, you’re in luck because Nationwide jewelry insurance can be added to your renters or homeowners insurance policy. 

Nationwide enjoys some of the best customer reviews and has a solid A+ AM Best rating based on its superior financial strength and years of experience in the insurance industry. In addition, clients praise Nationwide’s excellent customer support.

Moreover, the optional endorsement known as Valuables Plus offers coverage for a wide range of valuables, including artwork, antiques, and, of course, jewelry items as well. 

As far as the cost goes, Nationwide jewelry insurance policies are considered one of the most affordable, in most cases, costing just around 1-2% of the value of the jewelry per year.

PROS:
  • Valuables Plus policy option
  • A+ AM Best rating
  • Reliable service
  • Easy to get quotes online
CONS:
  • Limited homeowners coverage for jewelry
PROS:
  • Worldwide coverage
  • Replacement cost coverage
  • No deductibles
CONS:
  • A State Farm agent required

What Is Jewelry Insurance?

The first thought that many folks might have when they purchase jewelry is, “What is jewelry insurance?” 

In short, jewelry insurance is a specialized type of insurance coverage designed to provide protection for jewelry items against unexplained loss or other incidents. Besides, these policies tend to be extremely affordable, protecting the value of your jewelry and making it well worth the investment.

Now, this brings us to the next obvious question of, “How does jewelry insurance work?” 

Jewelry insurance provides coverage for the entire replacement value of the insured jewelry. Therefore, it is the best option to invest in. Moreover, a stand-alone jewelry insurance policy from any provider named above will offer coverage in case the jewelry items get damaged, stolen, or lost. In contrast, homeowners insurance covers only a fraction of the jewelry cost. 

Since jewelry insurance is very affordable, it pays to choose a policy that suits your needs. If you have invested in jewelry, it is advised to take out a stand-alone jewelry insurance policy for better coverage, even if you already have homeowners or some other insurance policy that offers coverage for jewelry items.

What Does Jewelry Insurance Cover?

So, what does jewelry insurance cover? A typical jewelry insurance policy is going to cover your jewelry items in case they get lost or stolen. It also offers coverage for the “unexplained loss.” It basically means losing your jewelry due to unusual circumstances that you can’t explain.

While other insurance policies only provide a certain amount of coverage, jewelry insurance gets you completely covered. 

Also, unlike other insurance policies that provide coverage for jewelry items, such as homeowners insurance, stand-alone jewelry insurance has no cap on the worth of the insured jewelry. This means it is possible to get insurance coverage for your jewelry, regardless of its total cost.

How Much Does Jewelry Insurance Cost?

Now that we’ve got a good idea of what jewelry insurance is and what it covers, it’s time to move deeper into the importance of jewelry insurance. Let’s answer the most frequently asked question by those looking for reliable jewelry insurance, which is, “How much is jewelry insurance?” 

Contrary to popular belief, jewelry insurance does not have to cost you an arm and a leg. While many folks think that jewelry insurance means having to pay high premiums and other hidden charges because of the expensive nature of the items being insured, in reality, it’s quite the opposite.

If you’d like an answer to the question, “How much does jewelry insurance cost?” then you’ll be surprised to know that a typical jewelry insurance policy is only going to cost you 1% to 2% of the total value of the jewelry being insured. That’s an incredibly reasonable price considering the solid coverage that most jewelry insurance providers have to offer.

With jewelry insurance prices so low, getting a policy is a no-brainer if you want to protect your jewelry from unforeseen circumstances. That being said, the total cost of the jewelry insurance policy also depends on a few factors such as:

  • The worth of the jewelry
  • The amount of insured jewelry
  • The condition of the jewelry at the time of getting a policy quote

Since jewelry can be easily stolen, to keep jewelry insurance coverage as affordable as possible, the standard policy liability limit for robbery is around $1,500. It means that the insurance provider will not pay more than the amount specified in the insurance agreement, which in this case is $1,500. However, the amount may vary depending on your circumstances and the particular insurance provider.

Does Homeowners Insurance Cover Jewelry?

Many homeowners insurance policies offer coverage for jewelry items; however, there are certain drawbacks of adding jewelry to standard homeowners or renters insurance policies. Both of them provide limited coverage for jewelry items, and more importantly, the limit of liability of your existing homeowner or renters insurance coverage might go up. 

On the other hand, investing in a stand-alone jewelry insurance policy will provide you with more coverage for different types of losses, giving a better level of protection for your jewelry items

FAQs

What is the best jewelry insurance company?

The best jewelry insurance provider is going to be the one that offers you the coverage you need for your jewelry items at the most affordable price. Keeping that in mind, any of the insurance providers mentioned above are great choices if you are searching for a reliable and trusted provider of jewelry insurance.

How to get insurance on jewelry?

While one can opt to include their jewelry items in their existing homeowners or renters insurance policy, it is advised to take out a separate jewelry insurance policy that offers far more coverage for your jewelry at an affordable rate.

How to get jewelry appraised for insurance?

While some jewelry insurance providers don’t require an appraisal for your jewelry items, others do. However, different insurance companies have their own rules on getting jewelry appraised.

This is why it is always best to ask your provider how to get the jewelry appraised. While some of them have their own appraisers, others might be okay with you having your jewelry appraised by other third-party appraisers just as long as the numbers match.

Is jewelry covered under homeowners insurance?

Yes, many insurance providers allow customers to include jewelry and other valuable belongings in their homeowners insurance coverage. However, this coverage is often limited and could end up bumping up the cost of your homeowners insurance as well.

Is it worth insuring jewelry?

Jewelry is a valuable investment, which can cost a lot of money. Since jewelry gets easily lost or stolen, it is advised to insure it. You should find the best jewelry insurance, offering plenty of features, such as worldwide coverage, quick claims processing, and affordable prices.